What will be the outcome of Michael Liu's appeal against his 41-month sentence by the end of 2025?
Sentence upheld • 33%
Sentence reduced • 33%
Sentence overturned • 33%
Court records or official announcements regarding the appeal outcome
California Woman Sentenced to 41 Months for $40,000 'Birth Tourism' Scheme
Jan 28, 2025, 02:30 AM
A California woman, Phoebe Dong, was sentenced to 41 months in prison for her role in a 'birth tourism' scheme. Dong and her ex-husband, Michael Liu, operated a business called USA Happy Baby, helping over 100 pregnant Chinese women travel to the U.S. to give birth, thereby granting their children American citizenship under the 14th Amendment. The scheme involved coaching clients on deceiving U.S. immigration officials, including using airports with perceived lax security and wearing loose clothing to hide pregnancies. The business charged clients as much as $40,000 for services, including accommodations in Southern California. Dong and Liu were convicted in September 2024 of conspiracy and money laundering. Liu received the same 41-month sentence in December 2024. The case was part of a broader Obama-era federal probe into 'birth tourism' businesses, which have long operated in the U.S. targeting clients from countries like China, Russia, and Nigeria. U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner ordered Dong's immediate custody despite her lawyer's request for a delay due to her children. The sentencing comes as President Donald Trump's executive order to narrow birthright citizenship was blocked by a federal judge. Dong plans to appeal the sentence.
View original story
Sentence upheld • 25%
Sentence reduced • 25%
Appeal dismissed • 25%
New trial ordered • 25%
Case Dismissed • 25%
No Appeal Filed • 25%
Conviction Upheld • 25%
Conviction Overturned • 25%
Sentence upheld • 33%
Sentence increased • 33%
Sentence reduced • 33%
Not Guilty Plea • 25%
Guilty Plea • 25%
Case Dismissed • 25%
Other Outcome • 25%
Trial scheduled • 25%
Guilty plea • 25%
Case dismissal • 25%
Not guilty plea • 25%
Conviction overturned • 25%
New trial ordered • 25%
Conviction upheld • 25%
Appeal dismissed • 25%
Convicted but no prison sentence • 25%
Convicted and sentenced to prison • 25%
Acquitted • 25%
Case dismissed • 25%
No appeal filed • 25%
Sentence upheld • 25%
Sentence reduced • 25%
Appeal denied • 25%
New trial ordered • 25%
Other outcome • 25%
Sentence commuted to life imprisonment • 25%
Death sentence commuted to life imprisonment • 25%
Other • 25%
Death sentence upheld • 25%
Death sentence overturned • 25%
Sentence increased • 25%
Sentence upheld • 25%
Appeal dismissed • 25%
Sentence reduced • 25%
Yes • 50%
No • 50%
No • 50%
Yes • 50%
1-5 • 25%
More than 10 • 25%
6-10 • 25%
None • 25%