Loading...
Loading...
Browse all stories on DeepNewz
VisitOutcome of legal challenge against Marais Poitevin basins by end of 2025?
All basins deemed illegal • 25%
Some basins deemed illegal • 25%
All basins deemed legal • 25%
Case unresolved • 25%
Court rulings or official announcements from the Bordeaux Administrative Court of Appeal
Bordeaux Court Declares Sainte-Soline and Three Other Poitou Reservoirs Illegal, Threatening Outarde Canepetière
Dec 18, 2024, 02:56 PM
The Bordeaux Administrative Court of Appeal has ruled that the permits for four irrigation reservoirs in the Poitou region, including the controversial one at Sainte-Soline, are illegal due to their threat to the survival of the protected great bustard bird, known as the outarde canepetière. The court found that the project could destroy part or all of the bird's habitat and has suspended the construction and future water fillings of these reservoirs until a potential derogation for protected species is granted. The water currently stored in the Sainte-Soline reservoir, the only one of the four that is completed, can be used this summer by connected farmers, but no further refilling is allowed. Environmental groups had challenged the state-issued permits for 16 water retention basins in the Marais Poitevin, known as 'bassines' by opponents, with the Sainte-Soline project sparking significant opposition following a violent protest in March 2023.
View original story
Yes • 50%
No • 50%
Reforms upheld • 25%
Reforms partially overturned • 25%
Reforms fully overturned • 25%
Pending legal decisions • 25%
Project approved • 25%
Project halted • 25%
Project modified • 25%
Ongoing litigation • 25%
Compensation awarded • 25%
No compensation awarded • 25%
Case dismissed • 25%
Settlement reached • 25%
Ruling in favor of Milieudefensie • 25%
Ruling in favor of Shell • 25%
Case dismissed • 25%
No decision by end of 2025 • 25%
Decision upheld • 25%
Decision overturned • 25%
New trial ordered • 25%
No appeal filed • 25%
Law upheld • 25%
Law struck down • 25%
Law revised • 25%
Case dismissed • 25%
Barrier deemed legal and remains • 25%
Barrier deemed illegal and removed • 25%
Compromise reached with modifications • 25%
Ongoing legal battles with no resolution • 25%
Yes • 50%
No • 50%
Land use upheld • 25%
Land use blocked • 25%
Land use modified • 25%
No legal challenges • 25%
Plan deemed legal and proceeds • 25%
Plan deemed illegal and halted • 25%
Plan modified through legal challenge • 25%
No significant legal challenge • 25%
Farmers' associations • 25%
Government • 25%
Environmental groups • 25%
No settlement • 25%