What will be the impact of H.R. 30 on immigration policy debates by March 31, 2025?
Increased focus on deportation • 25%
Shift towards comprehensive reform • 25%
No significant impact • 25%
Other impact • 25%
Analysis from major news outlets and policy think tanks
U.S. House Votes on H.R. 30, Nancy Mace's Bill to Deport Illegal Immigrants for Sex Crimes and Domestic Violence
Jan 16, 2025, 03:41 PM
The U.S. House of Representatives is currently voting on H.R. 30, the Preventing Violence Against Women by Illegal Aliens Act, introduced by Representative Nancy Mace. The bill aims to make illegal immigrants who commit sex crimes or acts of domestic violence inadmissible and deportable. Supporters of the bill, including Representatives Harshbarger, Murphy, Gonzales, Walberg, Owens, and Feenstra, argue that it is necessary to protect American women and children from violence perpetrated by illegal immigrants, citing cases like that of Rachel Morin. They attribute the need for such legislation to the Biden administration's open border policies, with Representative Mike Collins noting that over 20,000 illegals have committed violence against women. On the other hand, Representative Jamie Raskin has criticized the bill, stating that existing criminal and immigration laws already address these issues effectively, and that H.R. 30 could harm survivors of domestic violence by setting back efforts to protect them.
View original story
Not voted on • 25%
Passes with tie-breaking vote • 25%
Passes with majority • 25%
Fails • 25%
File lawsuit • 25%
Lobby for amendments • 25%
Organize protests • 25%
No significant action • 25%
Mixed opinions • 25%
Decrease in support • 25%
No significant change • 25%
Increase in support • 25%
No significant change • 25%
Increased support for stricter policies • 25%
Decreased support for stricter policies • 25%
Increased support for lenient policies • 25%
Partially Upheld • 25%
No Challenge • 25%
Upheld • 25%
Struck Down • 25%
Mixed/Other • 25%
Increase • 25%
Decrease • 25%
No Change • 25%
Increased Deportations • 25%
New Visa Restrictions • 25%
Pathway to Citizenship • 25%
No Significant Changes • 25%
Policy remains undecided • 25%
Pro-H-1B policy adopted • 25%
Anti-H-1B policy adopted • 25%
No significant change • 25%
Polarized opinions • 25%
No significant change • 25%
More favorable • 25%
Less favorable • 25%
Tied vote • 34%
Passes with majority • 33%
Fails to pass • 33%